Intuit (NASDAQ:INTU) delivered a classic ‘good quarter, bad outlook’ earnings reaction. Q4 revenue and adjusted earnings comfortably beat expectations, but management’s fiscal 2027 guidance points to a much sharper slowdown than investors had been expecting.
The shares fell sharply after hours — around 12% — adding to a brutal 2026 performance in which the stock had already fallen ~44%.
| Intuit (NASDAQ:INTU) | Price: $314.86 (~-12%) | Market cap: ~$86.0bn |
For UK investors, the key question is therefore no longer simply whether Intuit is a high-quality software company. It is whether the current valuation adequately reflects slower growth, TurboTax weakness, Mailchimp stagnation and the disruption/transition caused by AI.
Q4: the numbers were actually good
Intuit reported fiscal Q4 revenue of $4.35bn, up 13.6% year-on-year, against Wall Street expectations of about $4.27bn.
Adjusted EPS was $4.03, versus expectations of roughly $3.58 — a sizeable beat of around 13%. Adjusted earnings increased 47%.
| Intuit FY26 Q4 | Actual | Consensus | Surprise |
| Revenue | $4.35bn | $4.27bn | +1.9% |
| Adjusted EPS | $4.03 | $3.58 | +12.6% |
| Revenue growth | 13.6% | — | Strong |
| Adjusted EPS growth | 47% | — | Strong |
So why did the shares fall?
Because the market values Intuit on future growth, not the quarter just completed.
The problem is FY2027 guidance
Management expects fiscal 2027 revenue of $23.279bn-$23.512bn, representing growth of approximately 9%-10%.
That compares with:
- FY2026 growth of approximately 14%
- Wall Street consensus of about $23.72bn
- implied consensus growth of roughly 11%
Even more significant is adjusted EPS guidance of $22.88-$23.12, compared with analysts’ expectation of around $27.32.
| FY2027 outlook | Intuit guidance | Wall Street | Gap |
| Revenue | $23.28-$23.51bn | ~$23.72bn | ~1%–2% below |
| Revenue growth | 9%-10% | ~11% | Material slowdown |
| Adjusted EPS | $22.88-$23.12 | ~$27.32 | ~15% below |
| Q1 revenue | $4.294-$4.313bn | ~$4.36bn | Below |
| Q1 adjusted EPS | $2.44-$2.48 | ~$4.04 | Below* |
*The EPS comparison is complicated by Intuit’s change to its non-GAAP methodology: from FY2027, share-based compensation is included. The company estimates SBC has a $5.81-per-share impact on FY2027 adjusted EPS.
That accounting change makes the headline EPS comparison look particularly ugly, so investors should not interpret the entire $4.20-ish consensus gap as an underlying collapse in profitability.
But the revenue reset is real.
Where is growth slowing?
The guidance gives investors a useful map of where the problems lie.
| Business | FY2027 guidance | What it means |
| Global Business Solutions | +13%-14% | Still strong |
| Consumer | +4%-6% | Significant slowdown |
| TurboTax | +2%-3% | Major concern |
| Credit Karma | +11%-13% | Still attractive |
| Mailchimp | 0% to -1% | Essentially stagnant |
This is why the results are more nuanced than the headline share-price reaction suggests.
QuickBooks and the broader business platform remain healthy. Credit Karma remains a genuine growth engine.
The bigger problem is that TurboTax and Mailchimp are dragging the overall growth rate down.
TurboTax is the biggest immediate concern
Intuit’s tax franchise remains enormously valuable, but management is changing its strategy.
The company wants to win more price-sensitive customers, particularly those earning less than about $50,000, even if that means sacrificing some near-term revenue per customer.
CFO Sandeep Aujla said the company is looking to attract these users with potentially free offerings and then monetise them through additional services.
This is essentially a customer acquisition investment.
Management’s argument is that a larger TurboTax customer base can subsequently generate more revenue through Credit Karma, financial products and higher-value tax services.
That strategy has a potentially attractive long-term payoff — but investors are being asked to accept lower ARPU now in exchange for potentially higher lifetime customer value later.
That is a difficult proposition for a market that had become accustomed to Intuit delivering premium growth.
Management’s message: sacrifice today for a stronger franchise tomorrow
CEO Sasan Goodarzi summed up the strategy:
‘We’re focused on scaling our Big Bets, accelerating customer growth, and making deliberate choices to create a stronger foundation for durable long-term growth.’
That is the bull-case interpretation.
The bear-case interpretation is simpler:
Management is using ‘customer growth’ to explain why monetisation is slowing.
Investors will therefore want evidence over the next 12-18 months that new customers actually become more valuable.
There is also a significant AI component.
Intuit is investing heavily in AI-powered financial assistance, accounting automation and its mid-market platform. The company believes AI can make QuickBooks and its other products substantially more useful rather than simply replacing them.
The timing is important. Intuit announced a 17% workforce reduction earlier this year as part of a push towards a leaner organisation and greater investment in its strategic priorities.
The analyst debate is changing
Analysts had already become more cautious before the results.
Mizuho, for example, cut its Intuit price target from $500 to $430 in August while retaining an Outperform rating. Analyst Siti Panigrahi argued that the shares were approaching ‘trough valuations’ despite the company’s strong cash generation and historically durable growth.
Truist went further, downgrading Intuit to Hold and cutting its target to $350 from $410, citing a softer growth outlook and lack of a near-term catalyst.
That creates an interesting disagreement.
Bullish analysts
See:
- the sell-off as excessive;
- Intuit’s competitive moat as intact;
- QuickBooks as a durable SMB platform;
- Credit Karma as an underappreciated growth engine;
- AI as potentially increasing customer engagement;
- today’s valuation as unusually depressed.
Bearish analysts
Focus on:
- TurboTax losing price-sensitive customers;
- slower Consumer growth;
- Mailchimp stagnation;
- AI potentially disrupting specialist software;
- a declining growth rate;
- management credibility following the earlier TurboTax disappointment.
Valuation: Intuit is no longer expensive by its own history
This is perhaps the most interesting part of the story.
Before the 2026 share price collapse, Intuit routinely traded at a 30x-plus forward earnings multiple.
By late August, Stockopedia put the shares at ~13x forward earnings, versus more than 26x in FY2024-25.
That represents a huge de-rating.
Software valuation comparison
| Company | Forward PE* | Revenue profile | Investment view |
| Intuit | ~14x | FY2027 +9%-10% guided | Cheap, but growth resetting |
| Adobe | ~10x | ~low-double-digit | Cheap mature software |
| Salesforce | ~14x | ~10%-11% | Similar AI/growth debate |
| ServiceNow | Premium ~27x | Faster growth | Higher-quality growth premium |
| Intuit historical | 30x+ | Double-digit growth | Former premium compounder |
*Approximate forward multiples based on Stockopedia August 2026 market data on a rolling 12m forward basis.
The striking point is that Intuit is now being valued much more like a mature software company than the premium compounder it once was.
That creates opportunity — but only if the business stabilises.
Bull vs bear case
| 🐂 Bull case | 🐻 Bear case | |
| Revenue | Growth reaccelerates above 10% | Falls towards high-single digits |
| TurboTax | New low-cost strategy rebuilds market share | Lower ARPU permanently damages economics |
| QuickBooks | AI increases customer value and retention | AI commoditises accounting software |
| Credit Karma | Double-digit growth continues | Credit-cycle weakness hurts monetisation |
| Mailchimp | Stabilises and improves | Remains stagnant/declining |
| Margins | Workforce cuts deliver strong operating leverage | Investment required to defend growth offsets savings |
| Valuation | Multiple rerates towards 18-20x | Remains around 12-15x |
| Share-price implication | Significant recovery potential | Further downside if estimates fall |
Investor verdict
Intuit is increasingly interesting at today’s valuation, but this is no longer the straightforward quality-growth purchase it appeared to be several years ago.
A classic ‘good quarter, bad outlook’ earnings reaction, the Q4 numbers themselves were encouraging. A 14% revenue increase and 47% adjusted EPS growth demonstrate that the underlying franchise has not suddenly collapsed.
But FY2027 tells investors something important: the next stage of Intuit’s story is likely to involve lower growth and higher execution risk.
The most important number to watch isn’t even EPS.
It is customer growth versus monetisation.
If Intuit can attract millions of new TurboTax users, cross-sell Credit Karma and financial services, increase QuickBooks engagement through AI and simultaneously maintain margins, today’s ~14x forward earnings valuation could look remarkably cheap in hindsight.
If customer acquisition simply means sacrificing revenue without producing higher lifetime value, the market could be right to treat Intuit as a slower-growth software company.
For UK retail investors, that makes Intuit more interesting after the de-rating — but also more speculative. The September 17 investor day could be particularly important because management will have an opportunity to explain how AI, customer acquisition and its ‘Big Bets’ can restore growth.
Bottom line: Q4 was a beat; FY2027 was the problem. The market has effectively moved the debate from ‘How fast can Intuit grow?’ to ‘Can Intuit turn today’s investment and lower pricing into tomorrow’s customer lifetime value?’ That is the key investment question from here.
Note: Intuit reports in US dollars, so UK investors also face GBP/USD currency risk. This is analysis rather than personal investment advice.
You might also like:
